The Quiet They Called a Cure
Wandering wombs, ice picks and diet pills: a history of making women manageable
I want to say this plainly at the start: I am angry writing this. Not in a vague way. I'm angry at something specific, and I have the receipts. For about two and a half thousand years, Western medicine kept finding new ways to explain women's minds as a problem located in women's bodies. Then it kept finding new tools to fix that problem. And over and over, the sign that the fix had worked was the same: she was quieter. She was easier to live with. She went back to her duties.
I don't think every doctor in this story was a villain. Many believed they were relieving suffering, and some patients really were suffering. But intentions are not just what people feel inside. They are also built into what counts as success. When you look at what these treatments were measured against, the pattern is hard to miss.
An animal inside an animal
It starts with philosophy. In Generation of Animals, Aristotle wrote that "the female is, as it were, a mutilated male." (Scholars still argue about how harsh the Greek word is. Some translate it as "deformed," others as "incomplete." The direction of the idea is clear either way: man is the standard, woman the deviation.)
Medicine gave that idea an organ. The Hippocratic writings of the fifth and fourth centuries BCE described a womb that could move around the body looking for moisture, causing different symptoms depending on where it ended up. Doctors used scents to coax it back down. In the Timaeus, Plato described the womb as an animal "desirous of procreating children" that wanders when it is left childless. Centuries later the physician Aretaeus wrote that "the womb is like an animal within an animal." Galen disagreed that it physically wandered, but kept the uterus at the centre of the explanation. The word we inherited, hysteria, comes from hystera: womb.
So the earliest framework already holds the whole logic. A woman's distress isn't really about her life. It comes from an organ that wants to be used for its proper purpose. The remedy points toward marriage and motherhood.
Cutting out the cause
In the nineteenth century, that logic became surgery. In 1866 the London surgeon Isaac Baker Brown published claims that removing the clitoris could cure hysteria, epilepsy and insanity. The behaviours he listed as symptoms included things like "a great distaste for her husband." The Obstetrical Society of London expelled him in 1867. The central issue was consent. Patients had not properly agreed to what was done to them, and he sometimes operated without telling their husbands. Much of the debate was about the consent of fathers and husbands. That alone tells you something.
In America, Robert Battey removed healthy ovaries in 1872, and "Battey's operation" spread. Historians estimate that around 105,000 women had their ovaries removed in the nineteenth century for nervous and mental complaints. Mortality estimates run from roughly 10 to over 30 percent. At one Pennsylvania state asylum it was done without patients' consent until 1893, when a state committee called it "brutal and inhuman."
The gentler option was the rest cure. In 1887 the writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman, suffering after the birth of her daughter, was told by a celebrated specialist (S. Weir Mitchell, the most famous nerve doctor in America) to "live as domestic a life as far as possible," to "have but two hours' intellectual life a day," and "never to touch pen, brush, or pencil again." She later wrote that following this advice brought her "so near the borderline of utter mental ruin that I could see over." She broke the rules, went back to work, and wrote The Yellow Wallpaper, "not intended to drive people crazy, but to save people from being driven crazy."
In Paris, Jean-Martin Charcot made hysteria a public spectacle at the Salpêtrière hospital. The famous painting of his lectures shows a woman, his patient Blanche Wittmann, collapsing in front of a room full of men. Even the pose was copied from an earlier drawing. Women's suffering became something to stage and watch.
Surgically induced childhood
Then came lobotomy. The first leucotomy was performed in Lisbon in 1935, and its inventor, Egas Moniz, received a Nobel Prize in 1949. In America, Walter Freeman developed a faster version in 1946, driving an ice-pick-like instrument through the eye socket. Roughly 40,000 people were lobotomised in the United States. A 1951 study found that nearly 60 percent of American lobotomy patients were women. In Ontario between 1948 and 1952, the figure was 74 percent. Sweden lobotomised at least 4,500 people between 1944 and 1966, mainly women.
Freeman said his aim was to relieve suffering. His own words show what that relief looked like. He called the result "surgically induced childhood." He described one patient as "smiling, lazy, and satisfactory," with "the personality of an oyster." He tracked his patients for years on charts that recorded whether they could do paid work or housework, and counted even reduced productivity as success. In letters to him, relatives reported that a woman had "calmed down quite a bit" and did her "own house-work." One daughter wrote that her mother had become "a pretty reliable dishwasher."
In 1941, Joseph Kennedy arranged a lobotomy for his 23-year-old daughter Rosemary, who had been described as irritable, prone to rages and sneaking out at night. He told his wife afterwards. Rosemary was left unable to speak intelligibly and lived the rest of her life in institutional care. The Soviet Union banned lobotomy in 1950, calling it "contrary to the principles of humanity." America kept going.
Mother's little helpers
By then, pills were taking over. Amphetamine was first marketed in pill form in 1937, and its maker told doctors that "the main field for Benzedrine Sulfate will be its use in improving mood." In 1950 it launched Dexamyl, amphetamine mixed with a barbiturate, sold for everyday "mental and emotional distress" and for weight loss. The thinking was that overeating was an emotional problem. A British study around 1960 found that 85 percent of amphetamine patients were women, and the largest age group was 36 to 45. The historian Nicolas Rasmussen calculates that a woman was about twice as likely as a man to be prescribed amphetamine to adjust her mental state. As late as 1970, one American GP explained that only amphetamine kept certain patients "capable of performing or even enjoying their duties."
Then came tranquillisers. Valium was released in 1963 and was America's top-selling medication from 1968 to 1982. Its ads featured women like "Jan," 35, "single and psychoneurotic." The Rolling Stones had already named the phenomenon in 1966: "Mother's Little Helper."
What the pattern shows
Hysteria was only dropped as a diagnosis in 1980, with the third edition of psychiatry's diagnostic manual. That is not ancient history.
Here is where I try to keep fact and interpretation apart. The facts: for centuries, women's distress was located in their reproductive organs. Women were the majority of patients for some of the most destructive treatments ever invented. And the outcomes doctors recorded were very often calm, compliance, slimness and the return to domestic work. My interpretation: when the measure of a cure is that a woman stops being a problem for the people around her, the treatment is serving them, not her. Relief and control got tangled together, and for a very long time almost nobody asked her which one she wanted.
Gilman did ask. She picked up the pen she had been forbidden to touch. I keep coming back to that.
Sources
- Aristotle, On the Generation of Animals, Book II (Platt translation). Text; see also "Passive and deformed: did Aristotle really say this?"
- "Wandering womb" (Hippocratic corpus, Plato's Timaeus, Aretaeus, Galen), with its cited sources.
- C. Tasca et al., "Women and Hysteria in the History of Mental Health," Clinical Practice & Epidemiology in Mental Health (2012).
- The Conversation, "The rise and fall of FGM in Victorian London" (Isaac Baker Brown).
- Lady Science, "Menstrual Madness and Ovary Removal in the 19th Century" (Battey's operation).
- Charlotte Perkins Gilman, "Why I Wrote The Yellow Wallpaper" (1913).
- "A Clinical Lesson at the Salpêtrière" (Brouillet, 1887).
- "Lobotomy": figures from Shorter 1997, El-Hai 2016, Ogren & Sandlund 2005, Raz 2013, Zajicek 2017.
- The Psychologist (BPS), "Looking back: Interpreting lobotomy patients' stories" (Freeman's patient letters).
- "Rosemary Kennedy," drawing on Kessler (1996) and Larson (2015).
- N. Rasmussen, "America's First Amphetamine Epidemic 1929–1971," American Journal of Public Health (2008).
- Science History Institute, "Fast Times: The Life, Death, and Rebirth of Amphetamine."
- History Hit, "Mother's Little Helper: The History of Valium."
- C. Owens & S. Dein, "Conversion disorder: the modern hysteria," Advances in Psychiatric Treatment (2006).